Older Post
Newer Post

California Ballot Measure Results: What Does It All Mean?

a bus, housing and businesses at an intersection in downtown Oakland

California voters supported new funding for housing programs. They rejected a measure that would have made it harder for local communities to raise revenue for housing, transportation, and parks. Photo by Aubrey Littleton for SPUR

In this year’s mid-term elections, voters sent a dramatic message at the federal level, enacting sweeping changes for elected offices. But in California, voters seemed to prefer more cautious approaches to housing, elections, and taxes when weighing in on state propositions. Here are some takeaways from the results as of November 13.

California voters supported new funding for housing programs to tackle the state’s ongoing housing crisis. Prop. 1, authorizing $10 billion in general obligation bonds for affordable housing and $1.25 billion in mortgage revenue bonds to support homeownership programs for veterans and military families, passed with 61% of the vote. Prop. 37, a revenue bond to support second mortgages for homebuyers, also passed, with 62% approval. SPUR supported both of these measures, recognizing the dire need to continue funding programs that address housing affordability.

Efforts to make sweeping changes to state tax policy failed. Voters considered five ballot measures on local and state tax policy. In general, efforts to fundamentally reform the state’s tax system failed. Voters appeared to reject proposals to enact brand-new wealth taxes, while supporting existing taxes and the government’s flexibility to spend revenues.

  • Prop. 40, which would have imposed a new, one-time 5% tax on billionaire assets, got a thumbs down from 53% of voters. The tax would have generated billions of dollars to help fund health care and education for lower-income Californians. However, opponents worried the tax would harm the state’s economy over the long term if it drove high-wealth individuals and companies to leave. The measure’s opponents, led by a political action committee founded by billionaires, spent more than $300 million to defeat the tax by mounting an opposition campaign to Prop. 40, and they funded two other measures to nullify the tax. SPUR did not arrive at a recommendation for Prop. 40 because, while it may have had significant potential benefits to lower-income Californians, it could also have lasting negative economic impacts.
  • Voters rejected the strict spending limits on new taxes required in Prop. 41 by a margin of 10%. In addition to requiring audits of special taxes, Prop. 41 would have imposed strict spending formulas, limiting the government’s ability to raise revenues for priorities such as housing, transportation, and infrastructure. SPUR opposed Prop. 41 because of those constraints and because it was primarily designed to kill Prop. 40.
  • Prop. 42, which prohibits the state from imposing new taxes on personal assets and retirements, won with 51.2% approval. The success of Prop. 42 indicates that voters are hesitant to create a new wealth tax in California. SPUR opposed Prop. 42 because of its restrictions on future progressive tax revenues, as well as its placement on the ballot as a strategy to nullify Prop. 40.
  • Voters preserved the existing rules for local governments to enact or increase certain types of special taxes. Prop. 43, which would have raised the threshold for approving new special taxes placed on the ballot by a citizen initiative from a simple majority to two-thirds, was defeated by 57% of voters.
  • Prop. 3, which makes the state’s income tax rates for higher-income families and individuals permanent, passed with 61% of voters. Prop. 3 amends the California Constitution to permanently set marginal income tax rates on the top 2% of earners. The tax, imposed in 2012, was due to expire in 2030. The revenues primarily support K–12 schools, community colleges, and children’s health care programs.

The state’s electorate remains concerned about protecting the environment and communities from the impacts of new development projects. Prop. 45 would have changed the California Environmental Quality Act to streamline the environmental review of a broad range of housing, transportation, energy, health, public safety, education, and water projects. Prop. 45 could have accelerated sustainable projects, such as infill housing near transit and zero-emission energy infrastructure, but it could also streamline environmentally harmful development, including subdivisions on the urban edge and polluting energy facilities. SPUR was unable to arrive at a recommendation for Prop. 45.

Voters overwhelmingly opposed enacting strict voter identification requirements but were divided on other election reforms. Prop. 39 would have imposed three new requirements on statewide voter rules, including requiring government-issued identification for in-person voting. The support for the measure was divided along partisan lines. Opponents of Prop. 39, including Governor Newsom and many Democratic leaders, mounted a visible campaign to defeat it and succeeded in convincing more than 60% of voters. SPUR opposed this measure as well.

Voters were more divided on other electoral reforms that received far less funding and media attention. Prop. 4, which would have enabled more local governments to adopt public financing programs, lost by a very narrow margin. Prop. 5 would change election rules by eliminating the option to elect a replacement during a recall, preventing a candidate from winning with less than a majority of votes. Prop. 5 won by four percentage points. SPUR recommended a Yes vote on both these measures.

The 2026 midterm election cycle saw record political spending for candidates and propositions. Overall, ballot measure campaigns raised nearly ballot measure campaigns raised nearly $800 million to get measures on the ballot through signature gathering and to run campaigns. According to CalMatters, the opponents of the billionaire tax spent $316 million to fight Prop. 40 and to support Prop. 42.

Ballot measures with strong coalition support fared better than those with divided constituencies. Prop. 3, which changes the constitution to make the state’s marginal income tax rates on top earners permanent, had broad-based support from the teachers union and other labor groups, and passed with nearly 61% of the vote. On the other hand, Prop. 40 split many traditional allies, including labor, health providers, and elected leaders, and lost.